May 20, 2008

Shantaram: A Captivating Tale from the Slums of Bombay, with an Indian Reader's Perspective

I've encountered diverse cultures and communities as an international aid worker. Gregory David Roberts' "Shantaram" offers a glimpse into the underbelly of Bombay (now Mumbai), India, through the eyes of Lin, a fugitive from Australia. However, for an Indian reader, the book presents a fascinating mix of familiarity and fresh perspective.

An Unforgettable Escape


The novel opens with Lin's daring escape from prison and his subsequent reinvention in Bombay. He navigates the bustling city, forming bonds with a colourful cast of characters – from gangsters and holy men to slum dwellers and Bollywood actors.

A Look in the Mirror

While the story is captivating, an Indian reader might find some descriptions of Indian life a little romanticized or lacking nuance. However, Roberts' portrayal of the city's underbelly – the slums, the mafia – feels authentic and gritty. It can be a confronting but important window into the realities that many Indians face.

Love for the Land

Despite the challenges, Roberts' love for India shines through. His rich descriptions of Bombay's chaos, beauty, and cultural tapestry resonate with many Indian readers. The portrayal of characters like Prabaker, the endearing guide, or conversations that shed light on Indian customs, can feel genuine and bring a smile.

A Story of Growth

Like you, the international aid worker, an Indian reader might find the first half, with its coming-of-age themes and humour, particularly engaging. Lin's journey of self-discovery and his friendships offer a heartwarming perspective.

A Recommendation with Reservations

"Shantaram" is a captivating read, but be prepared for its length and some graphic content. The story is character-driven, and the first half shines with its portrayal of Bombay's diverse characters and Lin's growth. While the latter half may feel less engaging, the novel's exploration of human connection and resilience makes it worthwhile.

Why This Book Matters

For those seeking a unique perspective on India or a story that celebrates the human spirit's ability to overcome adversity, "Shantaram" is a rewarding read, especially for Indian readers. This book offers a chance to see your own city through a foreigner's eyes, sparking reflection and appreciation for the complex and vibrant land you call home.

No comments:

Post a Comment